Table 5. Comparison of roofs in timber, reinforced concrete, and steel structures

Aspect Timber structure Reinforced concrete structure Steel structure
Primary roofing materials Timber shingles, asphalt shingles, cross-laminated timber (CLT) panels, timber rafters Concrete slabs, precast concrete panels Steel sheets, metal roofing panels, corrugated steel
Weight Lightweight Very heavy, requires strong structural support Moderate weight, lighter than concrete but heavier than timber
Thermal insulation Good natural insulation Low insulation, additional layers required Moderate insulation, often requires extra insulation
Fire resistance Requires fire-retardant treatment Excellent fire resistance Requires fireproof coatings
Moisture resistance Prone to moisture damage, requires waterproofing Naturally resistant to water but prone to cracks Good moisture resistance but prone to corrosion
Durability Requires regular maintenance Highly durable with minimal maintenance Durable but requires corrosion protection
Construction speed Fast with prefabricated components Slow due to concrete curing time Fast with prefabricated steel sheets
Environmental impact Eco-friendly, renewable material High carbon emissions during concrete production Moderate carbon footprint, recyclable material
Maintenance Requires regular inspection and treatment for moisture Minimal maintenance Requires regular corrosion and coating checks